Traditional Gnostic Teaching on Purgatory
---
# Cathar’s Teaching on Purgatory
The doctrine of purgatory has been a central teaching of the Roman Catholic Church for centuries. According to this doctrine, after death, souls of the faithful who have died in a state of grace but still carry venial sin or temporal punishment undergo a purification process in a place called purgatory before entering heaven. The Church teaches that the prayers, masses, and offerings of the living can shorten the duration of this purification. But is this doctrine biblical? And what did the Cathars, a medieval Gnostic sect, believe regarding purgatory?
## The Roman Catholic Teaching on Purgatory
Roman Catholicism teaches a tripartite afterlife: heaven, purgatory, and hell. Souls that die in mortal sin face eternal damnation in hell, while the righteous, if not perfectly purified, go to purgatory—a temporary state of cleansing. This belief is used to justify practices like masses for the dead, indulgences, and prayers intended to relieve souls from purgatory.
However, the term *purgatory* does not appear in the Bible or the Nag Hammadi texts, the latter being a collection of early Gnostic writings. The concept of purgatory arose later in Church history and is not explicitly supported by Scripture.
## The Cathars and Their Rejection of Purgatory
The Cathars (or Albigenses), flourishing in the 12th and 13th centuries primarily in southern France, were a Gnostic sect who held beliefs starkly opposed to Roman Catholic teachings. They rejected purgatory, the invocation of saints, infant baptism, and the doctrine of transubstantiation.
The Cathars believed in a dualistic worldview, dividing the cosmos into forces of good and evil. They regarded material existence as flawed or evil and sought spiritual purity. They denied that souls undergo any purification after death, thus rejecting purgatory entirely.
Ralph of Coggeshale documented similar beliefs among the Pauliciani and Bogomils—other Gnostic groups sharing Cathar ideas. These sects rejected prayers for the dead and purgatory, emphasizing a direct and simple faith without elaborate rituals.
## Biblical Examination of Purgatory
The doctrine of purgatory lacks direct biblical support. The Scriptures emphasize that salvation and cleansing from sin occur through faith in Christ, baptism, and a life lived in obedience—not through a postmortem purification.
* **Hebrews 9:14** says Christ’s blood “purges your conscience from dead works,” showing cleansing happens in life, not after death.
* **1 Corinthians 5:7** exhorts believers to “purge out therefore the old leaven,” indicating sin’s removal in this present life.
* **2 Corinthians 6:2** states, “Now is the day of salvation,” emphasizing salvation is experienced now, not delayed after death.
* **Matthew 25:31-34** and **Revelation 22:12** depict judgment at Christ’s return, when all righteous receive their reward simultaneously, not at staggered times after death.
* **Hebrews 11:39-40** confirms that the faithful receive their reward collectively after the final judgment, not at various stages after death.
Moreover, the Old Testament uses terms like “Sheol,” often translated as “hell,” but literally meaning “the grave” or “place of the dead” (e.g., Psalms 49:6-9). The idea of a purgatorial state as a separate realm developed later, influenced by non-biblical traditions.
## The Nature of Death and the Afterlife According to Scripture and Cathar Thought
The Cathars believed, in line with certain biblical interpretations, that death results in unconsciousness or “sleep” until the resurrection at Christ’s return. They rejected the idea of souls wandering in an intermediate purgatorial state.
The Catholic notion that souls undergo conscious torment or purification after death is not explicitly supported by the Bible. Instead, Scripture suggests that death is the end of conscious existence until resurrection (Ecclesiastes 9:5; Psalms 146:4).
Furthermore, salvation and sanctification are processes occurring in this life through faith and obedience (Galatians 6:8). Sin is purged by baptism and continual spiritual growth, not by suffering in a purgatory after death.
## The Role of the Priesthood and Masses
Catholic doctrine teaches that priests can assist the dead through masses and prayers, reducing time in purgatory. The Cathars, and later Protestant groups influenced by their ideas, rejected this. They believed that no earthly rituals or offerings could influence the soul’s state after death.
The Bible supports this by declaring:
* **Psalm 49:7-9:** “No one can by any means redeem his brother, nor give to God a ransom for him... that he should still live forever.”
* **Hebrews 5:7:** Even Jesus “offered up prayers and supplications... and was heard because of His godly fear,” showing intercession is possible, but not through human manipulations or rituals.
Thus, the Cathar rejection of purgatory and masses for the dead aligns with biblical principles emphasizing personal faith, repentance, and God’s judgment rather than church-administered postmortem interventions.
## Historical Impact and Persecution
The Cathars’ refusal to accept purgatory and other Church doctrines posed a significant threat to Roman Catholic authority. Pope Innocent III issued orders for their suppression, endorsing violent persecution to eliminate their influence. The Albigensian Crusade was a direct result of this opposition.
The Cathars’ challenge to purgatory also influenced Protestant Reformation theology. Like the Cathars, Protestants reject purgatory, prayers for the dead, and indulgences, emphasizing salvation by faith alone and direct access to the Scriptures.
## Conclusion
The Cathars, as a Gnostic sect, firmly rejected the Roman Catholic doctrine of purgatory. Their teaching aligns with biblical texts that place the purification from sin in this present life through faith, baptism, and obedience rather than after death in a special intermediate state. They denied the efficacy of masses or prayers to shorten suffering after death and rejected the hierarchical priestly mediation claimed by the Roman Church.
The biblical witness supports the Cathar view that the righteous are rewarded at the final judgment and that death leads to unconsciousness until the resurrection. The idea of purgatory lacks scriptural foundation and reflects later Church developments rather than apostolic teaching.
In this light, the Cathars’ teachings on purgatory stand as a biblical corrective to the medieval doctrine, encouraging believers to focus on present faithfulness rather than posthumous purging.
---
Is there a purgatory ?
And if so, can the priest by his masses bring the faithful out of it ?''
The Roman Catholic Church teaches that the undying souls of men leave their bodies at death. The wicked (those who die in mortal sin) go to hell for eternal torment. The righteous, dying with unforgiven venial sin or undischarged temporal punishment, go to a painful purification before being fit for heaven.
Purgatory is a half-way house between 'heaven' and 'hell'. The Roman Catholic church teaches that Purgatory is a place of purging, in which the soul will suffer for a while before being fit to gain salvation in heaven. The prayers, candle-burning and financial gifts to the church of a person and his friends is supposed to shorten the length of time that the soul suffers in 'purgatory'.
The word Purgatory is not used in the Bible nor the nag hammadi texts
The Albigenses (also known as Cathari), named after the town of Albi, where they had many followers. They had their own celibate clergy class, who expected to be greeted with reverence. They believed that Jesus spoke figuratively in his last supper when he said of the bread, “This is my body.” (Matthew 26:26, NAB) They rejected the doctrines of the Trinity, the Virgin Birth, hellfire, and purgatory. Thus they actively put in doubt the teachings of Rome. Pope Innocent III gave instructions that the Albigenses be persecuted. “If necessary,” he said, “suppress them with the sword.”
Protestants, like Cathars, rejected the medieval Roman doctrine of transubstantiation and infant baptism. Like Cathars and Waldensians, Protestant Churches encourage laymen to read the scriptures for themselves. Most accept women as ministers, and most affirm the dignity of labour. Churchmen themselves are increasingly working for a living rather than living off tithes. Protestant theology is that of mitigated dualism, embracing predestination and rejecting the Catholic position on Free Will. Protestants, like Cathars, reject the medieval Roman Catholic notion of Purgatory, along with the practice of praying for the dead, and the entire system of indulgences.
The Jews had originally had no concept of an afterlife, but under Greek influence they had developed an ill-defined belief in an afterlife by the time of Jesus Christ. (The words translated as hell in the Old Testament actually mean grave or rubbish-tip). In the 2nd Century BCE the Jews had developed a belief that there was a afterlife in heaven or hell. Ideas such as Purgatory and Limbo were developed much later. More conservative Jews at the time of Jesus still held ideas of an afterlife to be an offensive novelty. As they pointed out the many punishments promised by God in scripture are all punishments in this world. None is promised for an afterlife.
Gnostic sects like the Bogomils, Pauliciani, Cathars rejected the doctrine of Purgatory
Ralph of Coggeshale goes into considerable detail of the doctrines of the Pauliciani in Flanders and England, and thereby establishes their complete identity with the Bogomils. They held, he says, to two principles-of good and evil; they rejected purgatory, prayers for the dead, the invocation of saints, infant baptism, and the use of pictures, images, and crucifixes in the churches ;
The Albigenses (also known as Cathari), named after the town of Albi, where they had many followers. They had their own celibate clergy class, who expected to be greeted with reverence. They believed that Jesus spoke figuratively in his last supper when he said of the bread, “This is my body.” (Matthew 26:26, NAB) They rejected the doctrines of the Trinity, the Virgin Birth, hellfire, and purgatory. Thus they actively put in doubt the teachings of Rome. Pope Innocent III gave instructions that the Albigenses be persecuted. “If necessary,” he said, “suppress them with the sword.”
Protestants, like Cathars, rejected the medieval Roman doctrine of transubstantiation and infant baptism. Like Cathars and Waldensians, Protestant Churches encourage laymen to read the scriptures for themselves. Most accept women as ministers, and most affirm the dignity of labour. Churchmen themselves are increasingly working for a living rather than living off tithes. Protestant theology is that of mitigated dualism, embracing predestination and rejecting the Catholic position on Free Will. Protestants, like Cathars, reject the medieval Roman Catholic notion of Purgatory, along with the practice of praying for the dead, and the entire system of indulgences.
The Jews had originally had no concept of an afterlife, but under Greek influence they had developed an ill-defined belief in an afterlife by the time of Jesus Christ. (The words translated as hell in the Old Testament actually mean grave or rubbish-tip). In the 2nd Century BCE the Jews had developed a belief that there was a afterlife in heaven or hell. Ideas such as Purgatory and Limbo were developed much later. More conservative Jews at the time of Jesus still held ideas of an afterlife to be an offensive novelty. As they pointed out the many punishments promised by God in scripture are all punishments in this world. None is promised for an afterlife.
Man has conceived that there is such a condition as life separate from God, and obedient to man’s thought; he has produced such a state of mind. When man changes his mind he will find that he lives in heaven continually, but by the power of his thought has made all kinds of places: earth, purgatory, heaven, hell and numerous intermediate states
The righteous are never promised salvation in heaven. The granting of salvation will be at the judgment seat at Christ's return, rather than at some time after death when we supposedly leave 'purgatory' (Matt. 25:31-34; Rev. 22:12).
All the righteous receive their rewards at the same time, rather than each person gaining salvation at different times (Heb. 11:39,40; 2 Tim. 4:8).
Death is followed by complete unconsciousness, rather than the activities suggested by the doctrine of purgatory.
We are purged from our sins through baptism into Christ and developing a firm faith in his work during our present life, rather than through some period of suffering after death. We are told to "purge out therefore the old leaven" of sin in our lives (1 Cor. 5:7); to purge ourselves from the works of sin (2 Tim. 2:21; Heb. 9:14). Our time of purging is therefore now, in this life, rather than in a place of purging ('purgatory') which we enter after death. "Now is the day of salvation...now is the accepted time" (2 Cor. 6:2). Our obedience to God in baptism and development of a spiritual character in this life, will lead to our salvation (Gal. 6:8) - not to the spending of a period in 'purgatory'.
The efforts of others to save us through candle-burning and other donations to the Catholic church, will not affect our salvation at all. "They that trust in their wealth...none of them can by any means redeem his brother, nor give to God a ransom for him...that he should still live for ever" (Ps. 49:6-9).
The righteous are never promised salvation in heaven. The granting of salvation will be at the judgment seat at Christ's return, rather than at some time after death when we supposedly leave 'purgatory' (Matt. 25:31-34; Rev. 22:12).
All the righteous receive their rewards at the same time, rather than each person gaining salvation at different times (Heb. 11:39,40; 2 Tim. 4:8).
Death is followed by complete unconsciousness, rather than the activities suggested by the doctrine of purgatory.
We are purged from our sins through baptism into Christ and developing a firm faith in his work during our present life, rather than through some period of suffering after death. We are told to "purge out therefore the old leaven" of sin in our lives (1 Cor. 5:7); to purge ourselves from the works of sin (2 Tim. 2:21; Heb. 9:14). Our time of purging is therefore now, in this life, rather than in a place of purging ('purgatory') which we enter after death. "Now is the day of salvation...now is the accepted time" (2 Cor. 6:2). Our obedience to God in baptism and development of a spiritual character in this life, will lead to our salvation (Gal. 6:8) - not to the spending of a period in 'purgatory'.
The efforts of others to save us through candle-burning and other donations to the Catholic church, will not affect our salvation at all. "They that trust in their wealth...none of them can by any means redeem his brother, nor give to God a ransom for him...that he should still live for ever" (Ps. 49:6-9).
